Calculated Risks has ratings and 46 reviews. Gerd Gigerenzer möchte uns mit seinem Buch “Das Einmaleins der Skepsis” zwei wichtige Dinge vermitteln. Cognitive scientist Gerd Gigerenzer says that because we haven’t learned statistical thinking, we don’t understand risk and uncertainty. In order to assess risk. Gerd Gigerenzer and Adrian Edwards. Bad presentation of .. the United States as Calculated risks: how to know when numbers deceive you. New York: Simon.
|Published (Last):||10 February 2008|
|PDF File Size:||19.65 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||13.68 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Enter your mobile number or email address below and we’ll send you a link to download the free Kindle App.
Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer – no Kindle device required. To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number. Would you like to tell us about a lower price? At the beginning of the twentieth century, H. Wells predicted that statistical thinking would be as necessary for citizenship in a technological world as the ability to read and write.
But in the twenty-first century, we are often overwhelmed by a baffling array of percentages and probabilities as we try to navigate in a world dominated by statistics. Cognitive scientist Gerd Gigerenzer says that because we haven’t learned statistical thinking, we don’t understand risk and uncertainty.
In order to assess risk — everything from the risk of an automobile accident to the certainty or uncertainty of some common medical screening tests — we need a basic understanding of statistics.
Astonishingly, doctors and lawyers don’t understand risk any better than anyone else. Gigerenzer reports a study in which doctors were told the results of breast cancer screenings and then were asked to explain the risks of contracting breast cancer to a woman who received a positive result from a screening.
Calculated Risks | Book by Gerd Gigerenzer | Official Publisher Page | Simon & Schuster
The actual risk was small because the test gives many false positives. But nearly every physician in the study overstated the risk. Yet many people will have to make important health decisions based rosks such information and the interpretation of that information by their doctors. Gigerenzer explains that a major obstacle to our understanding gigfrenzer numbers is that we live with an illusion of certainty.
Many of us believe that HIV tests, DNA fingerprinting, and the growing number of genetic tests are gerf certain. But even DNA evidence can produce spurious matches.
We cling to our illusion of certainty gigernezer the medical industry, insurance companies, investment advisers, gierenzer election campaigns have become purveyors of certainty, marketing it like a commodity. To avoid confusion, says Gigerenzer, we should rely on more understandable representations of risk, such as absolute risks.
For example, it is said that a mammography screening reduces the risk of breast cancer by 25 percent. But in absolute risks, that means that out of every 1, women who do not participate in screening, 4 will die; while out of 1, women who do, 3 will die. A 25 percent risk reduction sounds much more significant than a benefit that 1 out of 1, women will reap.
This eye-opening book explains how we can overcome our ignorance of numbers and better understand the risks we may be taking with our money, our health, and our lives. Read more Read less. Kindle Cloud Reader Read instantly in your browser.
Customers who bought this item also bought. Page 1 of 1 Start over Page 1 of 1.
How to Make Good Decisions. The Intelligence of the Unconscious. The Joy of x: In one example, he describes a surgeon who advised many of his patients to accept prophylactic mastectomies in order to dodge breast cancer.
In a two-year period, this doctor convinced 90 “high-risk” women without cancer to sacrifice their breasts “in a heroic exchange for the certainty of saving their lives and protecting their loved ones from suffering and loss. If the doctor or his patients had a better understanding of probabilities, they might have chosen a different course.
Fans of Innumeracy will enjoy Calculated Risksas will anyone who appreciates a good puzzle over numbers. If a woman aged 40 to 50 has breast cancer, nine times out of 10 it will show up on a mammogram. On the other hand, nine out of 10 suspicious mammograms turn out not to be cancer. So are many people who seek certainty through numbers, says Gigerenzer, a statistician and behavioral scientist.
Calculated Risks: How to know when numbers deceive you: Gerd Gigerenzer
His book is a successful attempt to help innumerates those who don’t understand statisticsoffering case studies of people who desperately need to understand statistics, including those gigerenser in AIDS counseling, DNA fingerprinting and domestic violence cases. Gigerenzer deftly intersperses math lessons explaining concepts like frequency and risk in layperson’s terms with real-life stories involving doctors and detectives.
One of his main themes is that even well-meaning, statistically astute professionals may be unable to communicate concepts such as statistical risk to innumerates. He tells the true story of a psychiatrist who prescribes Prozac to a patient and warns him about potential side effects, saying, You have a 30 to 50 percent chance of calcuated a sexual problem.
But what the doctor really meant is that for every 10 people who take Prozac, three to five may experience sexual side effects, and many have no sexual side effects at all. All innumerates buyers, sellers, students, professors, doctors, patients, riks and their clients, politicians, voters, writers and readers have something to learn from Gigerenzer’s quirky yet cwlculated book.
Copyright Cahners Business Information, Inc. See all Editorial Reviews. Product details File Size: November 10, Sold by: Share your thoughts with other customers.
Write a customer review. Showing of 34 reviews. Top Reviews Most recent Top Reviews. There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later. Uncertainty in life is accepted. We are forced to deal with it regularly in gigerrnzer daily lives.
But do we really understand the risks associated with this uncertainty? For most of us, I’d say probably not. In many cases certainty is an illusion according to Gigerenzer. We are generally beset by what he calls innumeracy – a lack of understanding of numbers and what they mean. For example, when we are presented with the risks of, let’s say, treatment with a statin drug, there are three ways to present the benefits – absolute risk reduction, relative risk reduction, and something called number needed to treat NNT.
In this case relative risks make something seem better, or worse, than it really is, but this is usually the numbers we are given by the medical profession. Gigerenzer shows through diagrams, charts and tables, and something called natural frequencies just how we can yerd misled by the way probabilities are presented. He follows this introduction with a chapter on breast cancer screening.
This chapter was an eye-opener. I think the information presented here should be required reading for any woman who has a mammography on a regular basis as a prophylactic measure. Misunderstanding of the results of the test can lead to unnecessary trauma and hardship. As Gigerenzer notes, “Women who are contemplating prophylactic mastectomy should know these numbers in order to be able to make an informed decision.
This requires education of not only the patient, but also the physician. In subsequent discussion about colorectal cancer and prostate cancer screening, he drives home the difference between conditional probabilities and natural frequencies.
Through numerous examples, charts, and diagrams, he clearly make the case for the use of natural frequencies these avoid the use of percentages and probabilitieswhich is so much clearer and is necessary for what he calls “informed consent.
Gigerenzer explains the importance of all of this and exposes the principle deficits of counseling.
He compares responses from nineteen counselors to these parameters; the disparity in the responses is truly amazing. He follows with very interesting chapters on wife battering and DNA fingerprinting. In the chapter on DNA fingerprinting, he explains the “chain of uncertain inference. Gigerenzer gives a detailed analysis of each of these steps leading from a DNA match to the proof of the guilt or innocence of the defendant. It’s all very interesting.
Not surprisingly, innumeracy can be exploited. Representations can be chosen that mislead the innumerate without being inaccurate. For instance, Gigerenzer shows a sample from an information leaflet written by 12 physicians that was available in the waiting rooms of German gynecologists. The leaflet on hormones and cancer demonstrated the potential cost increased risk of breast cancer as an absolute risk while showing the potential benefit a decreased risk of colon cancer as a relative risk.
This clearly made the cost appear smaller and the benefit larger. This calculatfd not inaccurate, just misleading. This is based on the show Let’s Make a Deal. Caculated you have three doors egrd choose from, and you pick number one.
The host shows that door three has a goat; should you switch to door number two? You will find the answer, and the explanation of the answer, enlightening. Gigerenzer follows this up with a three prisoner problem which is similar. I think I’ve gotten the best and most in-depth explanations of these problems I’ve ever read. The author ends with a chapter showing us how to teach clear thinking when it comes to the numbers game, and includes a glossary of all the technical terms used in the book.
I actually read all the definitions gigerenzeg the glossary as they were very informative. You can learn a lot from this book. I hope I have been able to give you a flavor for what’s in this book. The point to take home is that there is so much uncertainty in numbers, especially in matters that can be life altering, that I definitely recommend this book as required reading for anyone who faces the risks discussed in this book.
It could be a matter of life or death – really! A wonderfully clear explanation of elementry probability concepts with examples of vital applications.
The book will appeal to anyone who is not scared-off gigwrenzer numerical examples sometimes quite detailed. It requires almost no algebra, though. This book is exactly the same as “Reckoning with Risk” by the same author. The two falculated are merely U.